News & Politics
Will Sotomayor Really Be Good for Women?
She hasn’t always been in her past rulings.
-
- |
-
- |
- |
- 14
In her widely circulated Law and Cultural Diversity Lecture at Berkeley Law School in 2001, Judge Sonia Sotomayor demurred from Justice Sandra Day O’Connor’s disingenuous suggestion that a wise man and woman would reach the same decisions. Instead, she said, in the quote that’s everywhere in the coverage of her nomination, "I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn't lived that life."
Sotomayor cited two studies showing that the outcomes in sex discrimination cases are slightly more favorable to women plaintiffs if there is a woman on the judicial panel. So maybe she is right in general about different experiences. But she herself is not a random judge in a study. And based on her record, we have little reason to believe that Sotomayor would be any more sympathetic to women than a male justice of similar political inclinations. Maybe that’s something senators should ask her about at her confirmation hearing.
We don’t know how Sotomayor would approach women’s issues on the Supreme Court, because her record is scant, what there is of it is mixed, and she did not take the opportunities available to an appellate judge to make her viewpoints known. Sotomayor was never a law professor. She has not set forth the kind of overall approach to women’s rights that academic writing encourages. Her judicial decisions in cases involving women are mixed. From the standpoint of women’s legal rights, unless biology is destiny, the appointment is a leap in the dark.
On abortion, Sotomayor ruled against the interests of abortion providers and recipients in two cases that came her way. She rejected a challenge to the gag rule, which cut off international funding for groups that talked about abortion, and she revived a claim by anti-abortion protesters that the police had violated their civil rights when clearing them away from the clinic. In the area of women’s civil rights, she sustained some claims of sex discrimination, harassment, and retaliation and rejected others. There is no consistent strain in her rulings. And the cases usually include an element of racial discrimination as well as sex discrimination.
Some appellate judges also make a record through what their opinions say—their reasoning as well as their rulings. In recent years, some of Chicago’s Seventh Circuit judges have done this; the best known is Judge Richard Posner. Judge Sotomayor’s opinions do no such thing. With one exception, nothing in her opinions hints at a broad understanding or deep commitments to any particular version of women’s legal status, other than applying the law and precedents to the facts before her.
The exception is a sex and race discrimination claim brought by a Hispanic woman, Yvette Cruz, against Coach Stores, after the company fired her. Although Sotomayor and the other two judges on her panel ultimately dismissed most of Cruz’s discrimination claims in a 2000 ruling, they revived Cruz’s action against Coach for subjecting her to a hostile work environment. The standard for succeeding with a hostile work environment suit is high, making these cases hard to sustain. Sotomayor and her panel had to decide whether Cruz’s complaint contained sufficient allegations for a trial. The judge’s opinion opens with an uncharacteristically graphic description of one of Cruz’s last days at work: “On that day, Cruz's co-worker, Herve Heriveaux, approached Cruz during her lunch hour and commented that her ‘nipples [were] erect.’ An argument ensued between Cruz and Heriveaux, during which Heriveaux stepped extremely close to Cruz and called her a "f ing cunt." Cruz then slapped Heriveaux, who responded by placing her in a headlock. The altercation ended when Cruz's supervisor intervened.”
Linda Hirshman writes "The Princess" column for Double X and is the author of Get to Work: A Manifesto for Women of the World. Before she retired, she taught Philosophy and Women’s Studies at Brandeis University.
SNL: Equal Opportunity Objectifiers
Jon Hamm spent most of the Saturday Night Live episode he hosted last night shirtless.
Confessions of a Woman Comedy Writer
Allison Silverman accepts one from New York Women in Film & Television (and tells us why it's rare).
Comments
free games adventure games
By: GamesOnline | Fri, 09/25/2009 - 07:47
free games adventure games games escape games
tiffany
By: tiffany77 | Thu, 09/24/2009 - 01:59
Tiffany rings Tiffany rings tiffany rings sterling silver rings sterling silver rings Tiffany Pendants Tiffany Pendants tiffany Pendants Tiffany Necklaces Tiffany Necklaces tiffany Necklaces silver necklaces silver necklaces
links london Friendship Bracelets
By: linksoflondon | Tue, 09/22/2009 - 21:28
links of london Ring links of london Ring links of london Ring links of london links of london Ring links of london Ring links of london Ring links of london Ring links of london Ring links of london Pendant links of london Pendant links of london Pendant links of london Pendant links of london Pendant links of london Pendant links of london Pendant links of london Pendant links of london Pendant links of london Pendant
calling Tsing-Loh
By: Davidsmith7 | Sat, 09/19/2009 - 18:19
Thank you, Jessica, for calling Tsing-Loh on her equating of marriage with parenting, economics and house management. And thank you, Meredyth, for reminding us that marriage can be, instead, a personally fulfilling partnership: "nothing more or less than the combination of two lives into a powerful shared experience of our world."
As a happily married, childless woman, I'm probably a little defensive about this. But it makes me CRAZY when people think the only reason to get married is to have children (with the economic partnership/shared household piece as a subset of that). People seem to feel that, since we can have rewarding relationships without marriage, it is only the responsibility for raising children that necessitates a legal contract. But I'm just idealistic enough to think that a publicly declared commitment to share one's life with somebody else is so important -- so mmeaningful -- that it justifies marriage in and of itself.
Sure, caring for children and a household puts a strain on a marriage. But I suspect that more strain is created by the very act of perceiving that marriage as simply a vehicle for parenting and household management.
I think the fact that I feel this way -- and that my husband does too -- might be part of the reason why we're still happily together (friendship, sparks, and all) after 17 years.
Of course, I also know that we are very lucky.
Buy Cialis
Viagra
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
thank u my dear دليل مواقع
By: haytham | Wed, 09/16/2009 - 11:27
thank u my dear
دليل مواقع بنات مصر دليل مواقع يشمل مواقع مصرية , مواقع سعوديه , منتديات , مواقع اخباريه , وكالات انباء , صحف , والعديد من المواقع المفيده
دليل مواقع - دليل مواقع
مرحبا بكلم فى موقع العاب بنات مصر العاب للبنات فقط جديده , العاب بنات , العاب تلبيس , العاب تلوين , العاب باربي , العاب طبخ , العاب سيارات
العاب
games , free games , on line games , game , girl games
games
العاب بنات جديده العاب للبنات متجدده بشكل يومي وحصريه
العاب بنات
ان كنتى تبحثي عن العاب بنات جديده ومنوعه بشكل يومي فيمكنك دخول موقع العاب بنات مصر
العاب بنات جديدة
هل انت من هواة المنتديات والمشاركة فى المنتديات شاركنا التميز فى منتدي منتديات بنات مصر
منتديات
تعرف على بنات مصر فى منتديات بنات مصر
بنات مصر
بنات
منتدي , مواضيع عامه , مواضيع مميزه , اسلاميات , قرأن كريم , صور , افلام , العاب , برامج
منتدي
حمل صورك فى مركز تحميل صور بنات مصر
تحميل صور
صور رومانسية , صور حب , صور بنات مصر , صور بنات جديده ,
msryat
صور
حمل صورك فى احلى مركز تحميل صور يمكنك تحميل 5 صور فى مره واحده
مركز تحميل
دردشة مصرية , تعارف فى احلي دردشة مصريه
دردشة مصرية
شات مصري
دردشة مصرية
احلي موقع دردشة , دردشة مصرية , دردشة للبنات
دردشة
شات بنات دردشة بنات شات للبنات فقط
شات بنات
شات بنات مصر
شات بنات مصر
شات ودردشة نسيتك , شات سعودي , دردشة سعودية , موقع شات شات شات نسيتك شات سعودي دردشة شات كتابى سعودي دردشة كتابية شات كتابي احلي شات كتابي سعودي في موقع نسيتك دوت كوم ادخل وتمتع بالشات شات سعودي
regarding the abortion protesters
By: Davidsmith7 | Fri, 09/11/2009 - 16:09
In the case regarding the abortion protesters, again, she was not ruling on whether their actions were legal or illegal, only on whether the police acted properly while arresting them. I don't know as many details on this case, but it doesn't seem to comment even on the restrictions around protesting at abortion clinics, focusing instead ONLY on the actions of the police. cialis online
People seem to feel that,
By: sukabumi | Mon, 09/07/2009 - 02:25
People seem to feel that, since we can have rewarding relationships without marriage, it is only the responsibility for raising children that necessitates a legal contract....thank you
Stop Dreaming Start Action | Rusli Zainal Sang Visioner | kenali dan kunjungi objek wisata di pandeglang | mengembalikan jati diri bangsa | Sukabumi | lowongan kerja | webdesign murah
I don't know how this
By: bananaripe | Tue, 08/25/2009 - 01:42
I don't know how this pregnancy happen , Just knowing that a nice cruise thailand helps me to enjoy a provestra night and carrying my pregnancy for 3 months now.
We will surprise to find the
By: wohuhuhua | Sun, 08/23/2009 - 11:33
We will surprise to find the high quality tiffany jewelry in much.
Everyone will focus on tiffany and co,
tiffany jewelry.
Choose, buy and shop for on sale tiffany jewelry including Tiffany & Co Silver Necklace, Pendants, Bangles, Bracelets, Earrings, Rings and Accessories. Tiffany Necklaces
Tiffany Rings
Of course she will, she will
By: Marlet | Sat, 08/15/2009 - 16:33
Of course she will, she will definately address that women can make it in many of the top jobs now
Free iPod | Free iPod Touch | Family Portrait Photographer