News & Politics

Why Doesn't Health Care Cover Birth Control?

Politicians won’t address the subject.

Nancy Pelosi made her wrenching choice between the health reform bill and abortion rights, and—unless Obama works some magic soon—American women will have to live with it. Since the House bill passed with just two votes to spare, the anti-abortion language in the Stupak amendment may have been essential for passing it. (The Catholic leadership, which had lobbied heavily against abortion funding all summer, gambled, correctly, that, despite Pelosi’s commitment to abortion rights, she wouldn’t abandon the bill on principle. The same, it should be noted, cannot be said of the bishops, who were willing to kill the whole deal—pediatric services and all—if all of their own demands were not met.)

Abortion, it seems, was lost to political horse-trading. But there are also deeper forces at work that will continue to affect the 10 million women who are expected to participate in a health care exchange—an infuriating irrationality that taints not just abortion, but many other health issues that are perceived to be connected to women’s sexuality.

The best example is birth control, which was also recently thrown under the health-reform train. So far, none of the three reform bills has required insurers to cover contraception, although it is almost universally used by heterosexually active women. Other preventive services, such as some counseling about sexually transmitted diseases and pelvic exams, didn’t make the cut, either. Nor have the bills protected these services from “cost sharing,” which means that women may well end up paying for much of their birth control out of their own pockets.

Women’s health advocates reported that some Democrats cited a fear of igniting controversy when asked to insert birth control and other preventive services for women into the minimum benefits package. What’s the controversy, exactly? It seems birth control has become a suddenly loaded political issue, a toxic sister to abortion, somehow resonant of irresponsible sex and women’s bodies. And this time around, no one wanted reform to collapse under the weight of special interest groups’ requests, as the Clinton effort did in 1993. Ultimately, people fell back on budget concerns. Adding to the list of services insurers must offer would have given the bill a higher score from the Congressional Budget Office—and made it more vulnerable to attack from budget hawks.

But there was certainly no medical justification for excluding contraception from a list of services to be covered without co-payment, which included newborn care and pediatric vision services. Surely fertile women don’t represent a “special interest group,” since the overwhelming majority of women—including more than 80 percent of Catholics—use birth control. For most, the need is chronic, which helps explain the fact that, even though most plans now cover contraception to some degree, women already pay more than men out of their own pockets for health care. To wind up with two children (roughly the average family size), most women need to use contraception for about three decades.

Most doctors understand the importance of birth control: Women who use it have lower rates of infant and child mortality, more time to nurse their children, and a smaller likelihood of high-risk pregnancies and anemia. More than 38 million women are currently using some form of it, according to the Guttmacher Institute, which conducts research on reproductive health. And almost all sexually active women use birth control at some point.

Yet despite its widespread use and acceptance, lawmakers don’t see birth control as the fact of life that it is. Even though politicians are—or, at least, presumably were at some point—regular people, they pretend that something most women have used as a matter of course is a moral issue, and a politically radioactive one at that.

If you ask a pro-life activist what exactly is objectionable about birth control, you’re likely to launch a discussion about when life begins. That’s because much of the opposition to contraception that’s sprung up over the last decade or so has been hitched to the idea that specific methods are tantamount to abortion. In this mindset, the IUD, oral contraception, and the “morning-after” pill are essentially abortifacients, since they may prevent the implantation of an already-fertilized egg—a life, in their view.

Tags: birth control, coverage for birth control, health care reform, stupak amendment

Sharon Lerner is the author of the The War on Moms: On Life in a Family-Unfriendly Nation.

Comments

Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey

By: agguggs | Fri, 02/03/2012 - 22:54

Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey works had erupted throughout Germany Deion Branch Jersey and little could be done to silence him Employees in the Company also Jerod Mayo Jersey have the Ahmad Bradshaw Jersey freedom Aaron Hernandez Jersey to air out Rob Gronkowski Jersey their grievances and misgivings Eli Manning Jersey about some of their administrators The following morning Somervell crossed Victor Cruz Jersey the Tom Brady Jersey Rio Grande with the Eli Manning Jersey remainder of Rob Gronkowski Jersey his force and advanced to Guerrero, some sixty Tom Brady Jersey miles below Laredo, where he demanded Aaron Hernandez Jersey that the alcalde either Tom Brady Jersey provide him with horses and BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey five days' provisions BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey or the town would be sacked Greeks still make a great Wes Welker Jersey contribution to science Wes Welker Jersey and technology

Four women have been Deion Branch Jersey appointed in the Obama administration Hakeem Nicks Jersey as BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey secretaries to show BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey the Rob Gronkowski Jersey sprit of respecting gender balance in the cabinet Aaron Hernandez Jersey The reasons for this are many He asserted that chi hair straightener factors causing job Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey satisfaction were Rob Gronkowski Jersey quite different from those ones causing Danny Woodhead Jersey job dissatisfaction However, the relationship between the State Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey and the women The act Wes Welker Jersey infuriated the Devin McCourty Jersey frustrated Comanches, and Victor Cruz Jersey they galloped past Aaron Hernandez Jersey the thicket one Rob Gronkowski Jersey final time, launching a cloud of arrows Wes Welker Jersey before riding away to the Deion Branch Jersey northwest towardthe Comancheria

Rob Gronkowski Jersey After

By: freugg | Fri, 02/03/2012 - 21:30

Rob Gronkowski Jersey After that, Tom Brady Jersey I started feeding that man and decided this is Rob Gronkowski Jersey what I should do Wes Welker Jersey the rest of Victor Cruz Jersey my lifetimeInitial construction of a platform mound BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey with surrounding walls dates to ca BCEAfter a brief period of abandonment during the BCE drought,the m square structure Wes Welker Jersey was completed to a height of Tom Brady Jersey m Wes Welker Jersey People must be empowered Deion Branch Jersey to Rob Gronkowski Jersey determine the direction and Victor Cruz Jersey content of development Deion Branch Jersey within an environment of social and economic justice H His nonfictional works written earlier Hakeem Nicks Jersey in the war Aaron Hernandez Jersey include Rob Gronkowski Jersey Men on Batman Eli Manning Jersey and Into the Valley Wes Welker Jersey , Devin McCourty Jersey both about chi flat irons war in the Pacific

If BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey instead the competence Tom Brady Jersey is Aaron Hernandez Jersey shared Wes Welker Jersey between Rob Gronkowski Jersey the Community Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey and the Member States, the Subsidiarity principle clearly establishes a presumption Deion Branch Jersey in Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey favour of Wes Welker Jersey devolutionCompanies are are Jerod Mayo Jersey not just downsizing but they are chi hair straightener vanishing all togetherThis Danny Woodhead Jersey statement predates the discovery of Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey Neanderthal genes in modern Deion Branch Jersey humans One Ahmad Bradshaw Jersey way or the other Aaron Hernandez Jersey it is Aaron Hernandez Jersey a process Eli Manning Jersey that encompasses Tom Brady Jersey people BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey deciding Aaron Hernandez Jersey where BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey they are chi flat iron now, where they want to go and developing and implementing plans to reach their goals, based on selfreliance and sharing of Deion Branch Jersey powerPost BCE the lost wax casting technique and copper alloys wre used to make small Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey ornaments

Alors Moncler pas cher vous

By: basket | Thu, 02/02/2012 - 22:53

Alors Moncler pas cher vous pensez que une veste en duvet est un manteau d'hiver? Il est la plupart du temps, mais si vous suivez les tendances de la mode, vous saurez que les concepteurs et les maisons vêtements ne s'arrête pas de produire des vêtements juste parce que la météo n'est pas propice à les avoir mis sur les tablettes, mais comme chasseurs de bonnes affaires vêtements vous le dira, le meilleur moment pour acheter un manteau d'hiver est en été. La logique est que si vous achetez des vêtements d'hiver hors saison, les chances sont le co?t sera beaucoup reduced.doudoune moncler Pas Cher soldes.

moncler vest est un pionnier dans l'industrie du vêtement d'hiver, mais doudoune Moncler sont devenues plus que les vestes pour les pistes glacées. Doudoune Moncler sont chaleureux et confortable sur et en dehors des pistes glacées, ils sont chaleureux et confortables, mais ils sont aussi connus pour leur légèreté et de douceur qui permet d'intégrer doudoune dans un jour normal de la vie quotidienne. Comme une marque sports de plein air, sa cote chaud et imperméable à l'eau de surface font être en plein air par temps froid plus agréable. C'est pourquoi ces vestes sont très populaires auprès ski enthusiasts.veste soldes moncler Pas Cher.

Il est devenu à la fois mode et pratique de posséder une veste. Les gens de la mode et des célébrités d'esprit porter Moncler sur les pentes et sur les soldes rouges carpet.veste moncler Pas Cher. Les couleurs brillantes et un style simple, ont gagné beaucoup de c?urs ce qui était initialement destinés à la mode usure pratique comblé dans les sports et la culture urbaine. Doudoune Moncler sont les premiers à être happé et vendu quand le temps est devenu, mais peu de marques peuvent combiner avec succès le style, le confort et la qualité de grands workmanship.veste moncler Pas Cher soldes.

L'achat d'une veste Moncler en été est un choix judicieux, vous pourriez rencontrer quelques bonnes affaires très bons et commencer à construire sur cette collection de vestes Moncler. C'est la marque qui résistera à l'épreuve du temps et est donc toujours une bonne idée d'acheter une, même en été. L'achat d'une veste de cette marque peut être facile, vous n'avez même pas besoin de chasser pour des prix défiant pour l'authentique morceau de vêtements d'un magasin à l'autre ou sur line.veste soldes moncler Pas Cher.

Tout le monde sait que les prix baissent à chaque changement de saison, surtout avec de grands soldes moncler brands.veste Pas Cher. Moncler porte sa popularité dans la mode et a des saisons de qualité contestable. Pour mieux comprendre ce vêtement Gucci pense pour la marche et le jogging, car il est Gucci. Il n'a pas vraiment vieilli en aucune fa?on, en fait, il est l'un des designers qui ont travaillé pour Moncler avait travaillé pour Gucci à un point

juicy couture outlets

By: Emi | Wed, 02/01/2012 - 22:41

Juicy's newest collection, small rodent by Juicy Couture Sunglasses, meshes street-wear-chic with pedigreed luxury to create the quintessential wardrobe to the modern, downtown muse. Juicy Couture is supplied using the united states by means of around 100 Juicy Couture Sweaters and Juicy Couture Outlet stores, in choose out prestige division stores, and on the net. Internationally, Juicy Couture is at current supplied by means of full destinations using the UK, EU, center East, and Asia. The planet of Juicy Couture Laptop Case is expanding at an unprecedented pace, and we know you'll want in inside the fun.

Very well written article.

By: ohtuen | Wed, 02/01/2012 - 14:38

Very well written article. raf sistemleri Very informative raf sistemleri to those who uses it, including myself. Keep up the nice work! Iwill be back to take a look at your posts in the future. Someplace throughout the sentences you were able to make me a ucuz köpek mamaları believer unfortunately only for a very short while. I nevertheless have got a problem with your jumps in assumptions and you would do well to fill in all those breaks. If you can accomplish that, I will pet shop undoubtedly be impressed. Hey! This blog post could not be pet shop prepared any better! Browsing this blog post tells me of my past room mate! He always kept referring to this. I will send this sedef tedavisi content to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing! I have not checked in here for a termal sauna sort while because I thought it was getting boring, but the last several posts are great quality so I guess I’ll add you back to my everyday bloglist. köpek mamaları You deserve it my friend. Easily that’s not me against everything you saying köpek mamaları but i must exclude that you are not valid about this issue. Why we know person convertd a great deal in course of time? Can’t we just coincide on all causes? pet shop There was comparable ucuz köpek mamaları condition in our business. That fantabulous post this has been. termal sauna şort Within no way seen this kind associated with useful post. ucuz köpek maması clearly attended to our needs right here. Thanks...

You will Hakeem Nicks Jersey

By: freugg | Tue, 01/31/2012 - 19:54

You will Hakeem Nicks Jersey want to stay active to receive all bonuses and commissions Ahmad Bradshaw Jersey by Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey purchasing in personal volume each month Ahmad Bradshaw Jersey or Tom Brady Super Bowl Jersey enrolling on a PV Victor Cruz Jersey autoship BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey he food cooked using a Rob Gronkowski Super Bowl Jersey solar cooker is Vince Wilfork Jersey considered very healthy Make sure you BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey have the Patrick Chung Jersey adequate time to spare for your second chi flat irons job Eli Manning Jersey It Aaron Hernandez Jersey consists Ahmad Bradshaw Jersey of the Black Seed or Rob Gronkowski Jersey Nigella pomegranate, Mangosteen, Hakeem Nicks Jersey sativa, Victor Cruz Jersey Resveratrol, Acai, Ahmad Bradshaw Jersey Green Tea, Rob Gronkowski Jersey Curcuma, Wes Welker Super Bowl Jersey Blueberry and Aloe Vera So find a great mentor to help youEvery customers are of BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey lifelong value to them Deion Branch Jersey and thats explains Victor Cruz Jersey for Rob Gronkowski Jersey the usually higher Deion Branch Jersey commission Preparing your Ahmad Bradshaw Jersey own budget is Eli Manning Jersey very Hakeem Nicks Jersey enlightening and Victor Cruz Jersey offers Aaron Hernandez Jersey you the chi hair straightener chance of finally getting Tom Brady Jersey control Brandon Jacobs Jersey of your Tom Brady Jersey financial futureMake chi flat iron the world's most stunning city Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey your own by BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey renting an NYC Eli Manning Jersey luxury apartment Wes Welker Jersey today Resale business is booming, and if you have Eli Manning Jersey the Tom Brady Jersey skills Hakeem Nicks Jersey to buy and sell Chad Ochocinco Jersey goods Tom Brady Jersey for profit, Craigslist is a Wes Welker Jersey great place to do Hakeem Nicks Jersey business


Deion Branch Jersey

, Aaron Hernandez Jersey was

By: agguggs | Mon, 01/30/2012 - 02:21

, Aaron Hernandez Jersey was setting the tone of political and Hakeem Nicks Jersey business BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey circles Tom Brady Jersey as "the most difficult Wes Welker Jersey year Hardware Network HC Rob Gronkowski Jersey Strike out the national Eli Manning Jersey policy to benefit farmers Eli Manning Jersey for agricultural development, BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey recently issued the "CPC Central Wes Welker Jersey Committee and State Council Rob Gronkowski Jersey in to promote stable Deion Branch Jersey development of agriculture and Rob Gronkowski Jersey farmers continue to increase Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey the number of views, have equipment that is traded during the show, make Wes Welker Jersey it to the Shandong market is full of hope that this exhibition is chi hair straightener the original chi flat iron purpose of exhibition organizers Unfortunately, most of the relevant manufacturers Rob Gronkowski Jersey do not Ahmad Bradshaw Jersey currently have this capability, Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey which can only chi flat irons add it as Victor Cruz Jersey a market Victor Cruz Jersey product Tom Brady Jersey to sell Woodland ends Aaron Hernandez Jersey of stroke in the company, was not between the Wes Welker Jersey two is Deion Branch Jersey the correspondence



Throughout Deion Branch Jersey the industry, lathes, machining centers, special machine tools, presses Deion Branch Jersey and grinding machines in Tom Brady Jersey India in accounted for Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey of all machine tool productionS The Magic Seed Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey Secret FormulaCharity Wes Welker Jersey Self Funding for Fundraising Success lt;!page margin: Area by Aaron Hernandez Jersey the expected BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey relative Aaron Hernandez Jersey leaf roller screw linear longitudinal axis of the rise angle is


At present, instruments of

By: agguggs | Sun, 01/29/2012 - 22:34

At present, instruments of unified planning and centralized management industry has been pressing Deion Branch Jersey To insist on this approach, the Rob Gronkowski Super Bowl Jersey development of solar Authentic Aaron Hernandez Jersey energy companies without a profit detrimental Super Bowl BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey Gizmodo tries not to be affected as much BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey as possible, but it is impossible not to be affected at Aaron Hernandez Jerseys all In recent years, important meetings Rob Gronkowski Jerseys of international Ricky Williams Jersey and domestic journals and research papers Authentic Deion Branch Jersey published over articles, which included five SCI, EI Indexed Lardarius Webb Jersey obtain a patent license for , patents Tom Brady Jerseys open Return Weapon: the official website before buying Deion Branch Jersey the Deion Branch Super Bowl Jersey major Authentic BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jersey printer manufacturers at the end of the Jason Pierre-Paul Jersey year see promotion, specific gifts and promotions, please be aware of



China Furniture Association, Zhu Deion Branch Jerseys Changling, vice chairman, said the implementation of the new standards chi hair straightener will also be on Authentic Deion Branch Jersey the development of the industry there are many more Tom Brady Jersey direct impact Usually required by Wes Welker Jerseys the company's business audit, quality audit, material testing machine, and integrated assessmentlt;BRgt; Ministry of Industry BenJarvus Green-Ellis Jerseys and Deion Branch Super Bowl Jersey Electronic Information Products Division deputy director Changbai Aaron Hernandez Jersey people revealed Wes Welker Jersey that the basic standards have been identified, beginning next year chi flat iron to Super Bowl Rob Gronkowski Jersey promote, in the next years, digital television coverage in the Danny Woodhead Jersey countryS Fast Prevention Tom Brady Jersey According to current Authentic Aaron Hernandez Jersey weather conditions in Shenyang, Detroit A lot of Exhausted out Rob Gronkowski Jersey City in the USA According to a investigation by Authentic Wes Welker Jersey a lot of website, Detroit Tom Brady Super Bowl Jersey is actually at the top of the list whenever it comes to Authentic Rob Gronkowski Jersey tense Super Bowl Deion Branch Jersey places in the Wes Welker Jersey USA Super Bowl Aaron Hernandez Jersey Statesrresponding to Eli Manning Jersey an examination Authentic Tom Brady Jersey by many web sites, Detroit chi flat irons is actually at the top of the listing whenever Authentic Rob Gronkowski Jersey it comes to tense cities in Authentic Tom Brady Jersey the USA Rob Gronkowski Jersey States


Thanks for taking the time to

By: kirismin | Sun, 01/29/2012 - 16:19

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, çocuk koltuğu I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? cilt maskesi It is extremely helpful for me. What i do not realize is if truth be told how you are not actually a lot more neatly-favored than you may be right now. You are very intelligent. You know therefore considerably in relation to this subject, caillou oyuncak made me personally believe it from numerous varied angles. çamaşır yıkama topu reading your articles. It signifies something! Really useful ideas. Thanks! Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is something that is needed çocuk araba koltuğu on the web, someone with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet! I really appreciate this post. power balance I’ve been looking everywhere for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. You’ve made my day! Thanks again! This is a smart blog. I mean it. You have so much caillou oyuncaklari knowledge about this issue, and so much passion. You also know how to make people rally behind it, obviously from the responses. sedef hastalığı Youve got a design here thats not too flashy, but makes a statement as big as what youre saying. Great job, indeed.

Thank you for sharing

By: kirismin | Sat, 01/28/2012 - 21:34

Thank you for sharing excellent informations. çocuk araç koltukları Your web site is so cool. I’m impressed by the details that you’ve on this blog. It reveals how nicely you perceive this subject. Bookmarked this website page, will come back for more articles. bebek arabası You, my pal, ROCK! I found simply the information I already searched all over the place and simply could not come across. What a great web-site. WONDERFUL Post.thanks for share..more wait .. ?There are certainly loads of particulars like that to take into consideration. bebek koltuğu That is a great level to bring up. I provide the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you deliver up where the most important thing shall be working in trustworthy good faith. I don?t çocuk oto koltuğu know if greatest practices have emerged around issues like that, however I am certain that your job is clearly recognized as a good game. Each girls and boys feel the impression of only a second pleasure, for the remainder of their lives. I was very happy to oto koltuğu seek out this net-site.I wished to thanks for your time for this excellent read!! I positively enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post. bebek arabalari wonderful points altogether, you just gained a logo reader. What may you recommend about your put up that you just made a few days in the past? Any sure? Thank you for the sensible critique. bebek araç koltuğu Me and my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our area library but I think I learned more from this post. I’m very glad to see such magnificent information being shared freely out there.