Twitter in Guatemala and Iran: Is it really a tool for democracy?

Iran is the latest proof for cyber-utopists that the Internet is our best hope for global democracy and progressive politics. Bloggers are deep in the debate about whether Twitter is responsible for organizing the street protests in Tehran, or merely reporting them. But there are some Twitter doubters out there, and I add myself to their ranks.

If Twitter is the face of democracy, who, exactly, does it represent? In Iran, like many developing countries, most of the Internet users are affluent, young urbanites. The poor, the illiterate, the less urbane are not online, and this muddies the picture. I don’t know about Twitter’s effect in Iran, but Guatemala’s own recent Twitter coup is case in point.

See Double X's gallery of photos from Guatemala.

An online video and a single Tweet incited tens of thousands of Guatemalans to participate in the biggest demonstrations of their 13-year-old democracy. This video shows lawyer Rodrigo Rosenberg just before he was shot in the head while riding his bicycle on Mother’s Day in Guatemala City. “If you are watching this message,” he says calmly, “it is because I was assassinated by President Alvaro Colom.” He then accuses the president, the first lady, and others of signing off on murder, corruption, and the laundering of public funds through a government bank for personal gain and to expense narco-traffickers.

A twitterer (“tuitero”) who saw the video urged people to withdraw their money from corrupt banks and was arrested. Outraged crowds took to the streets to demand the president resign. Guatemala was hailed as another victory for democracy by technology.

But the president has plenty of supporters, although they are not likely to be online. They are mainly poor farmers and workers from the rural areas. The vast majority are Mayan Indians who rely heavily on benefits from the president’s social programs. Many are illiterate and only speak K’iche’, the most common native spoken language there–not the Spanish, much less the English, used on Twitter and Facebook.. Their concerns are mainly subsistence-related and do not easily feed a first, let alone a “Second Life."

During the country’s brutal 36-year Civil War, military governments fought left-wing guerrillas and destroyed Mayan populations who were said to harbor them. The war ended in 1996 and left at least 250,000 dead. Colom lost several relatives during Guatemala’s dirty war and vowed to stop the “mano dura” or “firm hand” approach of his running mate Perez Molina, a former army general who once took on the insurgency. Once elected, Colom focused on creating jobs and addressing the country’s dire poverty.

We still don’t know whether Mr. Rosenberg was murdered by opponents of the left who wanted to overthrow Colom, or if he was killed precisely as the video suggests, by Colom’s own allegedly crooked inner circle. What we do know is that Colom is a center-left democrat whose social and tax programs have rattled the country's conservative elite.

Had I not come to know something about the situation on the ground in Guatemala City, Rosenberg’s posthumous testimony surely would have had me swearing that the president is an enemy of the People and the Ideal, plus a crook and a murderer. But the web, although it has a bracing immediacy, doesn’t tell the whole truth. If those most traumatized by a legacy of violence and poverty aren’t yet able to participate in the debate, can we really say that the ’net has a democratizing effect? Particularly when, as in countries like Guatemala, the concerns of the unvoiced are in direct conflict with the political agenda of the cyber community?

Tags: democracy, guatemala, iran, twitter

Elizabeth Lazar is a freelance writer and research consultant in International Program Development at Northwestern University. Her e-mail is lizarmuir@gmail.com.

Comments

Coach Outlet Online

By: caicai123 | Mon, 02/06/2012 - 04:38

tiffany and ugg

By: zhenhua | Wed, 02/01/2012 - 09:17

Tiffany Jewelry online store , There are Tiffany Necklace , Tiffany Rings , Tiffany Bracelet , Tiffany Bangles , Tiffany Beads Bracelets , Tiffany Beads Necklace , Tiffany Charms , Tiffany Cufflinks , Tiffany Earrings , Tiffany Key Rings , Tiffany Accessories , Tiffany Sets ,Tiffany 1837 ring ,Tiffany 1837 ring Sterling silver titanium Return to 1837 heart pendant and Tiffany Watches Cheap for sale about Tiffany Jewelry!

Cheap ugg boots on sale , UGG Adirondack Boots , UGG Bailey Button Boots , UGG Bailey Button Fancy , UGG Bailey Button Krinkle , UGG Bailey Button Triplet ,UGG Fox Fur Boots , UGG Fringe Cardy ,UGG Highkoo Boots , UGG Jimmy Choo Boots , UGG Kensington Boots , UGG Knightsbridge Boots , UGG Mayfaire Boots , UGG Nightfall Boots ,UGG Payton Boots ,UGG Ultimate Bind , UGG Ultimate Boots , UGG Ultra Short , UGG Ultra Tall , UGG Upside Boots ugg boots saleonline store.

Cheap Ugg Boots online shop , Cheap Ugg Jimmy Choo , Ugg Kensington , Ugg Knightsbridge , Ugg Nightfall , Ugg Fox Fur , Ugg Tess , Ugg Bailey Button Boots , Ugg Bailey Button Fancy , Ugg Bailey Button Krinkle , Ugg Bailey Button Triplet Cheap Ugg Boots for sale!

UGGs on sale online store, UGGs Jimmy Choo , UGGs Knightsbridge , UGGs Adirondack Short , UGGs Adirondack Tall , UGGs Ashur , UGGs Bailey Button , UGGs Bailey Button Fancy , UGGs Bailey Button Krinkle , UGGs Bailey Button Triplet ,UGGs Kensington , UGGs Man , UGGs Mayfaire , UGGs Nightfall Tall , UGGs Retro Cargo , UGGs Swell Tall , UGGs Woman for sale UGGs on sale!

Tiffany Jewelry online store , There are Tiffany Necklace , Tiffany Rings , Tiffany Bracelet , Tiffany Bangles , Tiffany Beads Bracelets , Tiffany Beads Necklace , Tiffany Charms , Tiffany Cufflinks , Tiffany Earrings , Tiffany Key Rings , Tiffany Accessories , Tiffany Sets ,Tiffany 1837 ring ,Tiffany 1837 ring Sterling silver titanium Return to 1837 heart pendant and Tiffany Watches Cheap for sale about Tiffany Jewelry!

Cheap ugg boots on sale , UGG Adirondack Boots , UGG Bailey Button Boots , UGG Bailey Button Fancy , UGG Bailey Button Krinkle , UGG Bailey Button Triplet ,UGG Fox Fur Boots , UGG Fringe Cardy ,UGG Highkoo Boots , UGG Jimmy Choo Boots , UGG Kensington Boots , UGG Knightsbridge Boots , UGG Mayfaire Boots , UGG Nightfall Boots ,UGG Payton Boots ,UGG Ultimate Bind , UGG Ultimate Boots , UGG Ultra Short , UGG Ultra Tall , UGG Upside Boots ugg boots saleonline store.

UGGs on sale online store, UGGs Jimmy Choo , UGGs Knightsbridge , UGGs Adirondack Short , UGGs Adirondack Tall , UGGs Ashur , UGGs Bailey Button , UGGs Bailey Button Fancy , UGGs Bailey Button Krinkle , UGGs Bailey Button Triplet ,UGGs Kensington , UGGs Man , UGGs Mayfaire , UGGs Nightfall Tall , UGGs Retro Cargo , UGGs Swell Tall , UGGs Woman for sale UGGs on sale!

affordable term life insurance

By: Jessyjen | Wed, 01/25/2012 - 06:55

These are one of the few posts that I actually care to comment on. I find this blogger an inspiration and am definitely worth following. I've become a subscriber too, so please keep me updated.

affordable term life insurance

Port Douglas Accommodation

By: ericstuart1006 | Tue, 01/24/2012 - 16:44

You gave nice ideas here. I done a research on the issue and learn most peoples will agree with your blog. Certainly, these practices are unfair; but they say that most of their rules are only to apply to people who overdraw.
http://shantara.com.au

sunshine beach accommodation

By: ericstuart1006 | Fri, 01/20/2012 - 01:27

This is a great web site. Good sparkling user interface and very informative blogs. I will be coming back in a bit, thanks for the great article. I have found it enormously useful....http://lamersunshine.com.au

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 01:13

http://www.barbourjacketswomen.biz
http://www.barboursale-2012.net

This season, Barber Jackets will be one of the most popular additions to the wardrobes of the most fashionable people around today. They have already been an admired feature on catwalks throughout the world, whether London, Paris, or New York, are Quilted Barbour Jackets this year's biggest fashion statement. Trendy, stylish, and sophisticated, anyone with even a passing interest in fashion would have heard of this manufacturer of outdoor jackets. To own a Barbour Quilted Jacket is to make a statement to the world: ‘I love fashion, and I know what's hot and what's not'. To wear Barbour Jacket is to imbue you with a feeling of royalty, of an impression of regal greatness; indeed, these Barbour International Jackets truly reflect a high-status in society.To be sure, the Barbour Jackets Women is an expensive way of ensuring you remain fashionable for another season. Nonetheless, the price is a reflection on quality and style, no other manufacturer of clothing has managed to convey the same messages that Cheap Barbour Sale has. The advantages of owning such a prestigious item of Barbour sale clothing far outweigh the expense of doing so.

Because of the natural classic look these Women Barbour Jackets , Barbour Jackets mens ,Childrens Barbour Jackets suggest about the wearer, they are clearly appropriate for many occasions. Whether you wear yours to the pub, or to the wedding of your closest friend, you can be sure that you will not look out of place. Moreover, these Barbour Ladies Jackets are suitable across the seasons, in winter, they Quilted Jacket keep the wearer wonderfully warm, in summer, they keep of the drizzle, a staple favourite of weather systems throughout the UK! Their specialist materials are much like silk in the qualities they provide, providing warmth during a cold spell, but equally, managing to keep you cool during a warm spell – this is no surprise, many ‘country' style devices provide these qualities, just think about the thatched house; cool in summer, warm in winter,that is Barbour Jackets sale.

Aside from the provision of all things practical – their weather proofing, their warmth and cooling properties depending on the season, the depth of their pockets, their protection from rain, etc – Barbour jackets are also a fantastic fashion accessory. The image they invoke is one of class and sophistication, and by wearing such an item, you will reflect the same sentiment. This season, they are particularly fashionable – given the townie/country look that touted by the fashionista throughout the world at present. Wear with a pair of chinos, or skinny jeans, and perhaps a lumberjack shirt and narrow tie, and you will ‘hit the hammer on the head' by way of fashion this season.

In terms of style and comfort, therefore, there is no better jacket than Barbour jacket, made from the finest quality and in the most fashionable designs; you cannot go wrong when purchasing Barbour jackets.

The Barbour jackets parka is one of the most long lasting types of Barbour sale protecting outfits available. The Barbour Jackets women has several features, that Barbour coats allow certain excess components be taken out. The Barbour international hoody and sleeves could be detached using the zips and buttons that Barbour uk permit reattachment. Each of these ladies Barbour jackets features makes Barbour quilted jacket suitable for everyday wear as well. Parka jackets Barbour bamburgh jacket are large outdoor jackets with hoods. Usually, Barbour men's jacket parka they are stuffed with down or synthetic down, Barbour men's vest are fur or flannel-lined and the hoods Barbour girls beadnell jacket are fur-lined as well. Parkas Rainbow International Jacket are designed to be all-weather-proof, supplying warmness boys chelsea jacket Barbour and rainwater protection. Parka outdoor Barbour Classic Duffle Coat are liked by those who enjoy winter sports.

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 01:02

http://www.barbourjacketswomen.biz
http://www.barboursale-2012.net

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 01:02

http://www.barbourjacketswomen.biz
http://www.barboursale-2012.net

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 01:00

http://www.barbourjacketswomen.biz
http://www.barboursale-2012.net

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 00:59

http://www.barbourjacketswomen.biz
http://www.barboursale-2012.net

There's No Such Thing as a Bad Election

Events in Iran prove that even a little bit of democracy is a powerful thing.

Anne Applebaum
|
June 15, 2009

News & Politics

Is Twitter Really a Tool for Democracy?

Comments

Coach Outlet Online

By: caicai123 | Mon, 02/06/2012 - 04:38

tiffany and ugg

By: zhenhua | Wed, 02/01/2012 - 09:17

affordable term life insurance

By: Jessyjen | Wed, 01/25/2012 - 06:55

Port Douglas Accommodation

By: ericstuart1006 | Tue, 01/24/2012 - 16:44

sunshine beach accommodation

By: ericstuart1006 | Fri, 01/20/2012 - 01:27

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 01:13

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 01:02

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 01:02

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 01:00

Cheap Barbour Sale

By: seatime | Tue, 01/17/2012 - 00:59

Related Articles

There's No Such Thing as a Bad Election

DoubleX

The Root

Good Morning America

Washington Post