Arts
Are Judd Apatow's Movies Just Chick Flicks for Dudes?
How Funny People, Knocked Up, and The 40-Year-Old Virgin allow men to explore complex emotions.
-
- |
-
- |
- 228
This is the third entry in a dialogue about the films of Judd Apatow and the state of the romantic comedy among Double X Managing Editor Jessica Grose, Slate critic Troy Patterson, and Variety contributor Lael Loewenstein. Read the first entry here, and the second entry here.
Troy and Jessica:
Glad to join the discussion. You’ve left me with plenty to contemplate.
Funny People is Judd Apatow’s most tonally ambitious movie. It’s also his least successful. Up until now the films he’s directed have explored male friendship and insecurity vis-à-vis heterosexual initiation and dating (The 40-Year-Old Virgin), and impending parenthood (Knocked Up). Funny People raises the bar: As Apatow described it to the L.A. Times’ John Horn, “It’s a mentor story. It’s a disease movie. It’s a coming-of-age movie. It’s a movie about trying to restart an old romance. It’s 11 different movies rolled into one.” And that’s its problem. In wanting to be so many different things at once, it does none of them particularly well.
For a female viewer, the earlier films offered a fascinating and hilarious window into the mechanics and rituals of male bonding, presented in Apatow’s signature combination of raunchy, male-centric bravado and woman-friendly emotional warmth. Virgin’s Andy (Steve Carell) and Knocked Up’s Ben (Seth Rogen) are likable geeks, socially awkward guys who, despite their remarkable ineptitude with women, are validated by their essential sweetness. Funny People’s Ira (Rogen) is struck from the same mold. Emotionally immature, coarse-humored and relatively inexperienced sexually, he can’t score with Daisy (Aubrey Plaza) to save his life.
When George Simmons (Adam Sandler) takes Ira under his wing, it’s the first meaningful relationship that Ira has had. Unlike the SmartTech colleagues in Virgin and the stoner dudes in Knocked Up, Ira’s fiercely competitive roommates (Jonah Hill and Jason Schwartzman) offer neither advice nor solace, but rather a daily diet of derision. With George, Ira finds a job (assistant/joke writer), a role (confidant) and, in effect, a family. It’s not for nothing that they’re named after the Gershwin brothers. But it’s a deeply complicated friendship, to be sure: “You’re my best friend,” George tells Ira, “and I don’t even like you.”
Without a doubt, the central relationship in Funny People is the bromance between George and Ira: their dialogue crackles and their scenes together spark with the love-hate dynamic that is one of the cornerstones of smart romantic comedy. By contrast, George’s chemistry with Laura (Leslie Mann), "the one who got away," feels flat and forced. Consequently, the movie’s second half, in which George gets a second chance when his disease goes into remission, suffers by comparison to the first.
Which leads me back to Jessica’s question: What narrative purpose does Laura serve? Though she’s ostensibly the love interest, I see her more as a catalyst for the inevitable demise (and subsequent rebirth) of the Ira-George relationship. Outwardly, the film’s love triangle consists of George, Laura, and her husband Clark (Eric Bana). But its more intriguing triangle involves Ira, not Clark. Although George nearly wrecks Laura’s marriage, it is actually Laura who poses the much bigger threat to the film’s central relationship when she shows Ira the depths of George’s narcissism. As Ira tells George, “You’re the only person I know who could have a near-death experience and learn absolutely nothing.” Only after George and Ira have severed their friendship—in effect, broken up—can Ira finally move forward with Daisy. And only after a period of isolation and introspection can George show any signs of growth and move toward a rapprochement with Ira.
Comments
Please email me if you are int
By: jakeblake | Thu, 02/09/2012 - 01:33
Please email me if you are interested Articles On Photography artistic fashion photography
cheap armani handbags
By: wang8426 | Thu, 02/02/2012 - 21:06
replica handbag
replica louis vuitton
chanel handbag replica
best designer handbag replicas
replica dior handbag
replica versace handbag
replica prada handbag
wholesale chanel
handbags uk
dior handbags uk
buy cheap designer handbag
cheap designer handbags
buy replica handbag
best replica handbag sites
fake handbags
replica designer bags
chanel bags
fake designer handbags
replica chanel handbags
replica bags
replica celine bags
replica watches
watches for men
mens watches
tudor 7149/0 replica
new replica watches
swiss replica watches
replica watches review
omega replica watches
replica cartier watches
panerai replica watches
replica watches review
replica watches quality
replica tag heuer watches
replica breitling
piaget replica watches men
replica hermes watches
fake piaget watches
piaget replica watches
replica oris watches
replica swiss watches
swiss replica watches
replica watch
replica watches
replica
omega speedmaster
tag heuer grand carrera calibre 36 replica
best swiss replica watches
u boat replica watches
replica swiss watches
swiss replica watch
swiss made
swiss made replica watches
fake watches
swiss replica watches
replica watch
replica watches
replica
replicas de relojes
relojes especiales
replique montre
replique
repliques montres
replique montres
replique montre rolex
replique montre suisse
montre replica
swiss replica
replica watches
tank francaise femme
réplique montre
chopard femme montres
chopard ice cube prix
chopard montre femme
Thanks for share
By: kedaiobat | Wed, 01/25/2012 - 14:59
Hello i think Jam Tangan and then Jam Tangan is the best. You can find Jam Tangan for your choice. But if you dont knew about Jam Tangan Replika or Jam Replika that is new product of Jam KW me and others Jam Tangan Replika and then Jam Replika so dont miss it for Jam Tangan Replika and Jam Replika iits. Dont Sewa Mobil Jakarta and then Pashmina Murah and then Risol. And then you Toko Bunga, Dekorasi Pernikahan, Kirim Bunga, Pesan Bunga, Kotak Seserahan and then Florist Jakarta and Pemancar TV for all. Thanks
After a brief karen millen
By: karenmillens | Wed, 01/18/2012 - 21:35
After a brief karen millen collection of Corzine on Capitol Hill, the focus of the investigation has been diverted to MF's ratings agency. If you're a member of the secret handshake club and have a billion dollars you can do whatever you want on karen millen karen millen Street. Until that's demonstrably no longer the case, American's will treat the karen millen coats jackets as they would a dealer of Three Card Monte. Wish #3: A Clear Presidential Front-Runner Gridlock is bullish the way aspirin cures headaches; a little is great but too much will literally kill you. America's fiscal Karen Millen Australia doesn't actually exist anymore. The Federal Reserve
when people have such raging
By: karenmillens | Wed, 01/18/2012 - 21:32
when people have such raging negativity about their karen millen dressesthat it "really interferes with having a good life." As an example she cites "someone who says, 'I'm just too ugly to go out today because my skin broke out.'" About 2% of the population has what's called Body Karen Millen brown dressDisorder (BDD), she says, in which minor imperfections are perceived as major and cause stress out of proportion to the reality. Wilhelm knows this territory well. She is director of both the obsessive compulsive and related disorders program and the cognitive-behavior therapy program at Massachusetts General Hospital/Harvard Medical School, where she is an associate professor of psychology, and founder of the hospital's Karen Millen champagne dressclinic and research unit. She wrote a book about the issue, "Feeling Good About the Way You Look: A Program for Overcoming Body Image Problems." is the online source for consumers seeking intelligent beauty and karen millen Irenlandcare news, advice, tips and Karen Millen dresses sale. Founded in 2005, features articles
your important karen millen
By: karenmillens | Sun, 01/08/2012 - 21:45
your important karen millen discount sale . If you want to be special at the party, it is a good idea to wear a purple dress. Here are some suggestions. If you have darker karen millen jaket sale , I suggest light purple dress for you. And dark purple may be better for people with lighter skin. Take Asian ladies for example, dark purple cocktail Karen Millen outlet may suit them better. However, it is still a personal interest and preference. I came across karen millen uk Swift, no doubt like many others, by virtue of “Gulliver’s Travels”. I had to study “Gulliver” as set work during a course, and I found it fascinating and very rewarding (and not merely a kid’s story).
ST - her voice goes from
By: karenmillens | Sun, 01/08/2012 - 21:38
ST - her voice goes from karen millen outlet to there, she is amazing At the end Lauren points out that Seacrest's new Karen Millen blue dress is Peaches, Peaches Seacrest, which makes me love her even more. +1 for that! Pia Toscano - I'll Stand By You, The Pretenders, I love this song. Great recording karen millen dresses . Wow, and she changes it up right away. It sounds like Carrie Underwood's version, only maybe even better. It's got a little country feel to it. It actually has the power and runs of Kelly Clarkson, with Carrie Underwood's tone. And maybe a little Celine Dion in there too. I'm a big fan. She's country, she's rock and roll, she's Italian or Latina also, right? She doesn't let that entirely define who she is. She's also gorgeous and looks a lot like the girl from New Orleans with the baby who got cut (her name escapes me right now but she looked a lot like Natalie Portman, and Pia looks like her. Her dress is a beautiful black beaded number, kind of flapper, but modern. Cocktail dress like all of the other girls, but it doesn't leave me feeling like I'm at a pageant or a prom.
you should go on American
By: karenmillens | Sun, 01/08/2012 - 21:38
you should go on American Idol'- I would have said something like "you should be on TV or in karen millen collection". Take that how you will. (Gossip: if you notice NONE of the Idol girls stood up for her, they'd be standing for everyone... snub!) Scores: Singing: 6 Outfit: 10 Stage Presence: 8 Judges: JL - liked it, not the best thing from her, not from the heart, RJ - loves the song, but she didn't bring karen millen outlet online different, not nearly as good as Kelly Clarkson's, didn't show herself in the best light, ST - wrong song for her, should be up a couple of keys (up?)
Awesome Blog..!
By: kezliura | Thu, 12/29/2011 - 01:40
If you need to achieve success within your small business it is important that you just have appropriate ability for instance alarme maison so as to take your business enterprise to new heights.
"The secret of managing is to keep the guys who hate you away from the guys who are undecided."— Casey Stengel
Awesome Blog..!
By: kezliura | Thu, 12/29/2011 - 01:39
The accomplishment of your own business will depend to a large degree on our own management techniques. For illustration it's important that we possess competencies similar to alarme de maison if we wish to do well.
"If you pick the right people and give them the opportunity to spread their wings—and put compensation as a carrier behind it—you almost don't have to manage them."
— Jack Welch