Published on Double X (http://www.doublex.com)

Home > The Lesson of Swine Flu Isn't Necessarily One We'd Planned on Teaching

The Lesson of Swine Flu Isn't Necessarily One We'd Planned on Teaching

H1N1 is luckily turning out to be mild in most cases, but it's still a pandemic—which means nationwide, hundreds of thousands of kids are home sick today. (Iowa reported that 10 percent of kids missed school in October). Parents seem to be heeding the requests (or in some cases, demands) that they keep even kids who aren't feeling that bad home, but shedding that old Protestant work ethic isn't easy. Shouldn't kids who could be in school go?

By: KJ Dell'Antonia

Posted: November 19, 2009 at 10:54 AM

SEO Headline: 
Swine flu and the Protestant work ethic.
Deck: 
<p>With H1N1, everything we learned about the Protestant work ethic goes right out the window.</p>
Blurb: 

H1N1 is luckily turning out to be mild in most cases, but it's still a pandemic—which means nationwide, hundreds of thousands of kids are home sick today. (Iowa reported that 10 percent of kids missed school in October). Parents seem to be heeding the requests (or in some cases, demands) that they keep even kids who aren't feeling that bad home, but shedding that old Protestant work ethic isn't easy. Shouldn't kids who could be in school go?

I'm no Protestant, but where I grew up, the work ethic was firmly instilled, religion or not. If you could stand, you got out of bed. If you could walk, you walked yourself right into the bathroom, put your clothes on, and went to school. In my family, only actual, active vomiting really constituted an excuse, and even then, under certain circumstances (big test, a team commitment), you might just be handed a bucket.

It's clear that in the case of pandemic flu, those rules can't and don't apply (it's also fairly clear that maybe they weren't the best rules in the first place). But if you're lucky enough to have kids home with only mild cases of the flu (blogging parents are reporting fevers that come and go while kids stay full of energy [1] and schools requiring that kids stay home for seven days [2]), what's surprising isn't so much how difficult it is to deal with missed work and bored children. What's surprising is how wrong it feels to let a kid who's not feeling that bad just ... stay home. It feels too lenient. It feels indulgent. Won't they learn that when the going gets tough, the tough watch a Scooby Doo marathon?

Maybe they'll learn that sometimes, the most responsible thing to do is admit that the world can keep going without you for a while.

 

Exclude From Table of Contents
Exclude From Table of Contents: 
No
  • H1N1 swine flu
  • xxfactor

Source URL: http://www.doublex.com/blog/xxfactor/lesson-swine-flu-isnt-necessarily-one-wed-planned-teaching

Links:
[1] http://mommyspeak.blogspot.com/2009/10/face-of-swine-flu.html
[2] http://www.redheadranting.com/h1n1-or-strep/