Sotomayor Gets Hysterical Again

I know that Sonia Sotomayor is a crazy, overemotional, hysterical, aggressive bitch because some anonymous lawyers told me so. On the other hand, she sounds quite rational in this 2002 speech on whether the gender or race of a judge should affect judicial decisions. The New York Times has the full text:

No one person, judge or nominee will speak in a female or people of color voice. I need not remind you that Justice Clarence Thomas represents a part but not the whole of African-American thought on many subjects. Yet, because I accept the proposition that, as Judge Resnik describes it, "to judge is an exercise of power" and because as, another former law school classmate, Professor Martha Minnow of Harvard Law School, states "there is no objective stance but only a series of perspectives - no neutrality, no escape from choice in judging," I further accept that our experiences as women and people of color affect our decisions. The aspiration to impartiality is just that--it's an aspiration because it denies the fact that we are by our experiences making different choices than others. Not all women or people of color, in all or some circumstances or indeed in any particular case or circumstance but enough people of color in enough cases, will make a difference in the process of judging.

Sotomayor outlines what strikes me as a fairly subtle position; impartiality is a noble aspiration all judges ought to share, but if we are clear-eyed we recognize that we will never quite get there. And in acknowledging our limitations as objective decision makers, it makes sense to appoint judges with diverse life experiences. If we cannot all converge on some hoped-for Platonic truth, we can at least try to ensure that one perspective doesn't dominate.

But subtlety is not a quality Congress is known to value. Through the lens of populist Republican conservatism Sotomayor's remarks on objectivity will read something like "there is no God, morality is for suckers, and I will decide cases based on how my period is making me feel that day." This may be the kind of thing an aspiring SCOTUS nominee does well to leave unsaid.

Tags: Sonia Sotomayor, Sonia Sotomayor; Supreme Court; judges

VIEW THIS CONVERSATION

Kerry Howley is a contributing editor at Reason Magazine and an Arts Fellow at the University of Iowa's literary nonfiction program.

Comments

Not the sale of tickets but

By: Nensi | Thu, 10/01/2009 - 13:17

Not the sale of tickets but transmission rights, sponsoring and merchandising in the meantime make up the largest part of sports association’s and sports club’s revenues with the IOC (International Olympic Committee) taking the lead. The influence of the media brought many changes in sports including the admittance of new ‘trend sports’ into the Olympic Games, the alteration of competition distances, changes of rules, animation of spectators hookah, changes of sports facilities, the cult of sports heroes who quickly establish themselves in the advertising and entertaining business because of their media value[65] and last but not least, the naming and renaming of sport stadiums after big companies. “In sports adjustment into the logic of the media can contribute to the erosion of values such as equal chances or fairness, to excessive demands on athletes through public pressure and multiple exploitation or to deceit (doping, manipulation of results …). It is in the very interest of the media and sports to counter this danger because media sports can only work as long as sport exists.

.

By: nextingp | Fri, 09/18/2009 - 18:42

casino online
casino online guide featuring objective reviews of the best casino online
casino online , exclusive bonuses, casino games and much more casino online bonus

Texas Holdem sites

By: martinss | Sun, 08/30/2009 - 15:26

7 card player 5 card player texas holdem gambling nolimit holdem omaha poker omaha poker rooms online poker play poker poker limits poker rooms top poker online casinos vip texas holdem texas holdem limits texas holdem limit texas holdem

good article

By: khemso | Fri, 08/28/2009 - 10:38

thanks for your article keep posting please don't stop
_______________
Gold Prices Today
اسعار العملات اليوم
Internet news blogs
Gamezia - Games News and Cheats
Recipe Pie
Recipe Soup
Gold Price and Currency
Projects Management
Currency Prices
Gold Prices
Hollywood Stars
Will Smith
Crafts Kids

FANTASTIC! post, I am looking

By: alex drake | Thu, 08/27/2009 - 01:54

FANTASTIC! post, I am looking toward this type of fantastic article, keep it up.

dissertation writing | dissertation help | custom dissertation | buy dissertation

Dear puppies for sale, read

By: saracarrol | Fri, 08/21/2009 - 12:01

I read her speech. I don’t know why people tell her crazy. I found her a good speaker with very clear logic!
Kittens

hey I got some problem with

By: saracarrol | Thu, 08/20/2009 - 23:23

hey I got some problem with the link. I fails to continue after few seconds. Can anyone help me?
Puppies for sale

TV images of street protests

By: Markweee | Mon, 07/20/2009 - 04:05

TV images of street protests following Iran’s disputed election offer perhaps the strongest argument against U.S. interference as a tool for democratization
Dissertations AND Courseworkns AND Thesis Help

Are inflammatory headlines

By: Smashing H | Mon, 05/18/2009 - 14:01

Are inflammatory headlines necessary?

More Kerry Howley, please

By: Mouse | Sun, 05/17/2009 - 21:20

I've read her blog and find this piece really refreshing.