The Latina Is Wiser than the White Man!

Emily, you pull out the critical quote from Sotomayor's speech: "I would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn't lived that life."

This quote does not go down easy. As Stuart Taylor pointed out last week, what if Samuel Alito had said: "I would hope that a white male with the richness of his traditional American values would reach a better conclusion than a Latina woman who hasn't lived that life." We would chuck him over to some Idaho compound, no?

Yes, it's true, Sotomayor is unabashedly embracing affirmative action, in a way you don't even hear much on campuses anymore. In that 2002 speech Sotomayor begins by counting up women and minorities, court by court, and then concluding, "sort of shocking, isn't it?" This is not even the subtle kind of affirmative action that UC-Berkeley (where she was speaking) now practices, but the old-school, bean counting kind.

But beyond that, Taylor was being unfair. Sotomayor was not talking about all cases. She was talking specifically about race and sex discrimination cases. In fact, the presence of female judges does seem to make a difference—not on all cases but on sex discrimination cases. Is this bias? Is it some defiance of logic? It seems perfectly natural to me. It does not apply in all cases, obviously (Clarence Thomas). And Sotomayor was a prosecutor in her past life, not a public defender.

Obama's phrase of today—"common touch"—seems all wrong, too, a little quaint and patronizing. But "empathy" and "curiosity"—two of his other words—seem about right. "Empathy" does not mean you lose your mind in a flood of hormone and tears. "Empathy" is not only available to women and minorities. It just means that sometimes you see things other people might miss, if only because you know what they look like.

Tags: identity politics, Sonia Sotomayor, Supreme Court, women judges

VIEW THIS CONVERSATION

Hanna Rosin Double X co- editor, reporter, prefer my friends live.

Comments

Attention and attentiveness

By: Nensi | Thu, 10/01/2009 - 05:59

Attention and attentiveness have become a new commodity for which a market developed. The amount of attention insurance quote that is absorbed by the media and redistributed in the competition for quotas and reach is not identical with the amount of attention, that is available in society. The total amount circulating in society is made up of the attention exchanged among the people themselves and the attention given to media information. Only the latter is homogenised by quantitative measuring and only the latter takes on the character of an anonymous currency.According to Franck best web hosting, any surface of presentation that can guarantee a certain degree of attentiveness works as magnet for attention, e. g. media which are actually meant for information and entertainment, culture and the arts, public space etc. It is this attraction which is sold to the advertising business. The German Advertising Association stated that in 2007 30.78 billion Euros were spent on advertising in Germany 26% in newspapers, 21% on television, 15% by mail and 15% in magazines. In 2002 there were 360.000 people employed in the advertising business digital cameras. The internet revenues for advertising doubled to almost 1 billion Euros from 2006 to 2007, giving it the highest growth rates.

Sotomayor is a very smart

By: jimb12345 | Thu, 09/24/2009 - 13:06

Sotomayor is a very smart women. She does make alot of sense on her views. i definitely do not agree with alot of her views. She should be a good supreme justice..
Car Hifi

good article

By: khemso | Fri, 08/28/2009 - 10:35

thanks for your article keep posting please don't stop
_______________
Gold Prices Today
اسعار العملات اليوم
Internet news blogs
Gamezia - Games News and Cheats
Recipe Pie
Recipe Soup
Gold Price and Currency
Projects Management
Currency Prices
Gold Prices
Hollywood Stars
Will Smith
Crafts Kids

I don't know how this

By: bananaripe | Tue, 08/25/2009 - 00:57

I don't know how this pregnancy happen , Just knowing that a nice cruise thailand helps me to enjoy a provestra night and carrying my pregnancy for 3 months now.

Now that is just plain

By: Marlet | Sat, 08/15/2009 - 18:46

Now that is just plain stupid
Free iPod | Free iPod Touch | Family Portrait Photographer

This sounds awful. Superbad

By: Markweee | Mon, 07/20/2009 - 01:36

This sounds awful. Superbad is one of my favorite films, I must have watched it 10 times already. But, I can't stand it when obvious copies come out that are just pathetic and a waste of money.
Theses AND Buy Dissertation AND Coursework Writing

This is a victory for women

By: unapologeticfeminist | Tue, 05/26/2009 - 14:48

Yesterday, I wrote an article trashing Taylor: http://unapologeticfeminist.com/2009/05/stuart-taylor-is-an-idiot

Today? We party.

Women first; ideology second!