Do Women Novelists Really Work in "Miniature"?

Do women novelists work in "miniature"? This was the question posed by the cover piece in the New York Times Book Review this weekend. The piece was a review of Kate Walbert's A Short History of Women, a novel that offers a canny fictional portrait of how women's rights have (and have not) evolved over time. In the book (which I haven't read in full yet) Walbert tries to summarize women's history by dramatizing it. At the opening of the piece, the review's author, Leah Hager Cohen, restates Virginia Woolf's famous quote about how we see men and women's novels differently: “This is an important book, the critic assumes, because it deals with war. This is an insignificant book because it deals with the feelings of women in a drawing room.” Ahh, I thought. Hager Cohen is going to take on the old dichotomies and demolish them! And she's going to do so in the Book Review itself, one of the few literary edifices that still shapes people's careers—and itself sometimes reflects these same old fallacious assumptions. She is going to create a revolution from within!

Alas, no. In fact, this review is a prime example of what I'll now call literary Stockholm Syndrome, in which women reviewers and writers all too eagerly embrace the sexist—and hell, yes, let's call it what it is—terms by which women's writing is still evaluated. An example. At the beginning of the review, Hager Cohen writes that Walbert's new book "delivers what feels like a reasonably representative history of women—at least of white, Anglo-Saxon women, over the past hundred-odd years. What is that history? What are its implications? And why should we care about them?" She goes on to explore those very large questions. But at the very same time, Hager Cohen buys into the notion that to write closely and intimately about women's lives (particularly their domestic lives) is somehow to deal in miniature. The final line of the piece is "Kate Walbert may work in miniature, but her scope is vast." I understand what Hager Cohen (an intelligent critic) is trying to do; but at the same time, I find myself frustrated that yet again a critic is buying into a language of smallness, of prettiness, we resort to when describing a woman's work; a language that we often wouldn't use, I am convinced, if the text in question were by a man.  This is why I call it literary Stockholm Syndrome: We have so identified with the captors that we are smitten with their superstructures, their rules, their way of seeing.

Of course there are women (and men) who work in miniature. I recognize that Walbert's work, which I know and like, can seem quiet, or still. But it doesn't seem to me that on the one hand a critic can say a book delivers a history of women for the past hundred odd years and at the same time say she does so by working in "miniature." It's just not logical. Or am I missing something obvious?

Tags: kate walbert, new york times book review, women novelists

VIEW THIS CONVERSATION

Meghan O'Rourke is a founding editor of Double X and the author of Halflife, a book of poems.

Comments

Women and Literature

By: manix | Fri, 11/27/2009 - 08:59

Because the widespread education of women was not common until the nineteenth century, the arena of British and American literature was once largely male dominated: the role of women was most often to inspire rather than to create. Since then, however, the literary contributions of women have become increasingly important. More and more women have become storytellers, poets and prophets, the authors of dreams and ideas--the voices to whom we listen.



cazare in Bucuresti

I think its a good post. Keep

By: CrinaBucuresti | Wed, 11/04/2009 - 08:56

I think its a good post. Keep up the good work !!
Rent a car Bucharest

Leah Hager Cohen, restates

By: hommerock | Wed, 09/23/2009 - 12:39

Leah Hager Cohen, restates Virginia Woolf's famous quote about how we see men and women's novels differently.

london botox | wrinkle treatment | botox injections

But at the very same time,

By: hommerock | Wed, 09/23/2009 - 06:01

But at the very same time, Hager Cohen buys into the notion that to write closely and intimately about women's lives (particularly their domestic lives) is somehow to deal in miniature. The final line of the piece is "Kate Walbert may work in miniature, but her scope is vast.

driver update scan

good post,I think

By: wallace530 | Fri, 09/04/2009 - 02:09

good post,I think so!abercrombie and fitch on Sale, Hoodies, Jeans, T-Shirts, Pants, Polos
abercrombie and fitch abercrombie fitch abercrombie cheap
abercrombie and fitch Abercrombie Men Tee abercrombie womens polos
abercrombie and fitch Men, women, and children's clothing and
links london accessories edhardylife a famous ed hardy store which sell directly ed hardy
clothing, shoes, boots, swim suit and other cheap ed hardy,
ed hardy cheap Ed Hardy ed hardy clothing,Providing authentic Ed Hardy Clothing with competitive price and fast,secure delivery.The famous brand by Don Ed Hardy 's Vintage Ed Hardy.Provides the best tiffany
jewellery, including Necklaces, Pendants, Bracelets, Earrings, Rings at the lowest prices.Tiffany Jewellery is the best online United Kingdom jewelry stores where
you can buy the cheapest
tiffany jewellery & Co silver jewelry. Our huge selection of
tiffany uk and
tiffany jewellery and
tiffany jewelry

Their lives are not that

By: ninanina | Sun, 08/30/2009 - 19:36

Their lives are not that narrow, I believe that. Women novelists are happy with what they are doing. In case of no, they won't keep doing the job. classifieds |article directory |bathroom vanity cabinets

good article

By: khemso | Fri, 08/28/2009 - 10:55

thanks for your article keep posting please don't stop
_______________
Gold Prices Today
اسعار العملات اليوم
Internet news blogs
Gamezia - Games News and Cheats
Recipe Pie
Recipe Soup
Gold Price and Currency
Projects Management
Currency Prices
Gold Prices
Hollywood Stars
Will Smith
Crafts Kids

In the book (which I haven't

By: mickhhp | Tue, 08/25/2009 - 18:30

In the book (which I haven't read in full yet) Walbert tries to summarize women's history by dramatizing it. At the opening of the piece, the review's author, Leah Hager Cohen, restates Virginia Woolf's famous quote about how we see men and women's novels differently: This is an important book, the critic assumes, because it deals with war.

inchirieri masini
bijuterii

I don't know how this

By: bananaripe | Tue, 08/25/2009 - 01:01

I don't know how this pregnancy happen , Just knowing that a nice cruise thailand helps me to enjoy a provestra night and carrying my pregnancy for 3 months now.

This site is interesting as

By: chrisawalik | Mon, 07/06/2009 - 05:22

This site is interesting as well as informative. Enjoyed browsing through the site. Keep up the good work. Greetings..

( Civil engineering degree and Special Education degree )